Canddi

Adobe Experience Makers Talk Cookieless

Adobe Experience Makers discussions about a cookieless future put customer trust and first-party data at the centre of digital experience. This article revisits those themes from our original 2022 report and explains what changed in the browser plans behind the debate.

What changed in the cookieless timeline?

The original article referred to a proposed Chrome phase-out in 2023. That deadline is no longer a reliable basis for planning. In April 2025, Google said it would maintain its existing approach to third-party cookie choice in Chrome and would not introduce a new standalone prompt. In October 2025, Google also announced the retirement of several Privacy Sandbox technologies, including Topics and Protected Audience.

For the historical background, Google’s 2021 privacy-first web announcement explains the direction being discussed at the time. Treat it as context, rather than a current implementation timetable. Check the documentation for each browser and advertising platform before making technical changes.

Why first-party data still matters

First-party data is information an organisation collects through its direct relationship with customers: for example, preferences they provide, enquiries they submit or purchases they make. A first-party cookie is a browser storage mechanism. The terms describe different things, and neither label automatically makes a use of data appropriate.

In the original Experience Makers coverage, Adobe’s Gabbi Stubbs emphasised the relationship between customer trust, willing participation and better experiences. That remains a useful starting point: explain the value a customer receives, ask for information with a clear purpose and make their choices understandable.

For example, a customer might choose the topics they want in a newsletter. Using those preferences to send relevant content is a clearer proposition than collecting more information simply because a tool allows it. Keep the experience useful even when someone declines optional tracking.

Trust depends on how data is used

The ICO’s guidance on storage and access technologies covers cookies, pixels and other mechanisms. First-party technology is not automatically exempt from the rules. The purpose, applicable exceptions and consent requirements need to be assessed; UK GDPR also applies where personal data is involved.

Questions for a data and experience review:

  • What customer need does each data item or tracking tool support?
  • Where is information collected, who receives it and how long is it retained?
  • Are the explanation and preference controls clear to someone using the site for the first time?
  • Do the site’s actual behaviour and supplier settings match those choices?
  • Who is responsible for reviewing the setup when tools or requirements change?

Use the answers to brief the people responsible for privacy, analytics and implementation. A new identifier or a different storage method should not be treated as a shortcut around these checks.

Three practical lessons for experience teams

Our original report also highlighted Adobe’s John Mackenney on long-term thinking, leadership and giving teams room to improve. Those themes translate into manageable work without depending on a single browser deadline.

1. Start with one customer journey

Choose a specific task, such as finding a course or completing an enquiry. Identify where users struggle and agree one improvement. Define success before changing the experience, so the team can distinguish a useful result from a change in traffic.

2. Test, measure and learn

Record what changed and compare suitable outcomes, such as completed enquiries and the quality of those enquiries. Note limitations in the data, including consent choices and differences between audiences. Avoid treating a dashboard number as a complete account of what customers experienced.

3. Investigate the reasons behind the numbers

Combine appropriate analytics with usability testing, customer feedback and conversations with support or sales colleagues. A lower completion rate may indicate an unclear form or missing information. Understanding the problem helps the team choose a better response than adding more tracking.

Build the skills behind better experiences

Clear content, usable design and confident creative production all contribute to customer experience. Explore Academy Class training options to discuss a suitable learning format for your team and the skills you want to develop.

Cookies